Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Not Accepting Orders
Delivery fee -
Min. order -
Free delivery above
Pickup
Delivery
Pickup Address:
Fresh Baked & Hand Crafted Treats
Cookies
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Cupcakes
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Luxury Gift Boxes
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Cinnamon Rolls
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
View our delicious seasonal offerings
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Shopping with us at a market and need to pay by card? Sarah Joy and her single card reader can only be in one place at a time, so if you’re checking out with a Joyful friend or team member, simply use this page to complete your purchase securely online.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Ready to order?
Ordering your cookies and cupcakes online from our bakery for local pick up has never been easier. We are based in New Florence, PA, and are joyful to serve our cookies to happy customers in Ligonier, Greensburg, Blairsville, and the surrounding Laurel Highlands. Personalize your cookie design by describing what you are looking for on the order form. We can theme your cookies to an event, wedding, or special occasion and build special shapes, such as flowers, hearts, and even logos.
If you need more cookie options, check out our Basic Dozen, Traditional Dozen, and Joy Ride Dozen! We also offer cupcakes with a wide array of flavor options.
Our small-town cottage bakery is licensed and inspected by PA Department of Agriculture, and we are located only a few miles from scenic Buttermilk Falls in Western Pennsylvania!
*All orders must be placed at least two weeks prior to pick up or delivery.